Why Black Lives Matter

How My Mind Was Changed

When I first heard the sentence, “Black Lives Matter,” my reflex response was, “Well, of course. All lives matter.” Human life matters. Your life matters, as does mine. Yellow and brown lives matter too. And white lives. All the wonderful colors of humanity matter because they clothe a human being, fearfully and wonderfully made in the image of God, endowed with the priestly dignity of Adam. We are kings, priests, and lords over the earth, image-bearers of our Creator. Biologically speaking, we are all the same species. There is no scientific or theological basis for what we call “race” based on the color of a person’s skin.

Over the past tumultuous weeks, I’ve begun to see and hear things from perspectives other than my own. It’s how I was raised and educated. If someone says something matters, it would be good to understand why it matters to them. I began to rethink the present and remember my own past. To say that race is merely a “social construct” not based in reality, as I myself have often said, is to speak only half a truth. The oft-unspoken tension between white and black people in America is a reality, and within that reality the color of one’s skin matters. Deeply.

Here then are some of the thoughts that changed my thinking about why black lives matter.

Black lives matter because we think George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, Bothan Jean, Michael Brown, and Eric Garner (to name just a few), are isolated instances of injustice, unfortunate mistakes, or the actions of a handful of bad people.  If only it were that simple.

Black lives matter because we are heirs of a deeply imbedded notion that the white European was superior and therefore entitled to colonize lands and enslave other peoples. It runs in the background of our national pride, our civil religion, our histories and mythologies. We don’t think about it because, like white noise in the cultural background, we’re accustomed to it. We don’t hear it but others do.

Black lives matter because slavery matters. The enslavement of black people by white slave owners lies at the heart of understanding black/white relations in our society. Slavery is a persistent fact of American history, too often glossed over, a fact that goes beyond the individual to the collective whole. I’ve never owned slaves, and my Ukrainian, Polish, and German ancestors did not own slaves, but I stand on a societal foundation that was built on the backs of black slaves. There is no escaping this black and white history. I can no more say to a black person “slavery ended 160 years ago, so get over it,” than a German can say to a Jewish person, “Auschwitz happened 80 years ago; it’s time to move on,” or a Japanese can say to a Korean, “let’s just forget about the past and let bygones be bygones.” History is memory. Black slavery is our history, a history that is lensed through a white or a black experience in America.

Back in the 1990s while we lived in St. Louis, my wife and I did a bicycle tour through Kentucky, stringing together a series of bed and breakfast inns. One inn was a classic southern plantation mansion with 12-foot doorways, 14-foot ceilings and walls that were nearly two feet thick to keep out the Kentucky heat. We slept in the immense library. The inn advertised all the charm and romance of the “antebellum south.” “This house was built by slaves,” the innkeeper informed us matter of factly during the tour. Being from the north, I’d never heard the phrase “built by slaves” in a house tour and didn’t know what to make of it. Here we were dining sumptuously and sleeping comfortably in a house built by enslaved black people. It diminished the “charm and romance” considerably.

When our nation’s constitution was framed on the lofty principles of liberty, justice, and equality, black lives mattered less than national unity, fair representation, and taxation. A slave was counted at 60% for the purpose of representation to ensure that the southern states weren’t overrepresented or overtaxed. To quote Alexander Hamilton, himself an opponent of slavery:

Much has been said of the impropriety of representing men who have no will of their own…. They are men, though degraded to the condition of slavery. They are persons known to the municipal laws of the states which they inhabit, as well as to the laws of nature. But representation and taxation go together…. Would it be just to impose a singular burden, without conferring some adequate advantage?


Black lives didn’t matter quite as much as representation, taxation, and national unity.

Black lives matter because their contributions to American history, culture, cuisine, art, science, and literature have been largely white-washed from the American curriculum. We learned about the Boston Tea Party and the Battle for Ft. Sumter, but no one told us about Jim Crowe laws or the Greenwood Massacre. Everyone loves barbecue, but do we know of its origins in the slaves of the Caribbean and west Africa? We know who John Glenn was but unless you saw the movie Hidden Figures (2016) you probably never heard of Katherine Johnson, Mary Jackson, and Dorothy Vaughan who were instrumental in putting Glenn into orbit. I didn’t.

Do the names W.E.B du Bois, Ralph Ellison, Zora Neale Hurston, James Baldwin, Benjamin O. Davis, Otis Boykin sound familiar? Not on my reading list. Jackie Robinson broke the “color barrier” in major league baseball in 1947. (Think about it. There was a “color barrier” in 1947, ten years before I was born!) He was hardly the first black man to play baseball and may not have even been the best, but we’ve forgotten all the names of those who played the game before him. They didn’t matter.

Black lives matter because being black mattered to those who segregated schools, neighborhoods, restrooms, restaurants, and drinking fountains. It mattered to the southern Democrats who fought hard to maintain segregation as the status quo even after the Civil Rights Act of 1964. It mattered to my childhood neighborhood that took measures to ensure no blacks would live in our white corner of the city. It mattered to those who shouted “N-lover” at my little sister for going to school while the neighbors kept their kids at home to protest desegregation. It mattered whether you were welcome in our churches, in local restaurants and bars, in nightclubs, movie theaters, and shopping malls.

Black lives matter because we were taught to be careful when going to the “colored neighborhoods,” so that our learned reflex would be one of distrust, fear, and defensiveness whenever we saw a black person. We were raised to see the world in black and white terms. We discriminated on the one hand, and we patronized on the other. We were content with the status quo so long as we could reap the advantages while handing out token favors to the disadvantaged. We institutionalized poverty and created a system of dependency that used black lives as a political bargaining chip. “Vote for me, and I will take care of you.”

Black lives matter because in so many ways, from so many perspectives, whether liberal, moderate, or conservative, whether urban, suburban, or rural, whether wealthy or poor, religious or irreligious, we have been saying in thought, word, deed, and silence that black lives matter only when they are useful to us. We say it when we discriminate and segregate. We say it when we patronize and paternalize. We say it when we say we don’t see it.  And we say it with our words and with our silence.

Jesus was not a white man. He was a semitic Jew with the ethnic heritage of His mother, a Galiean from Nazareth. He did not have long flowing brown hair, fair skin, and azure blue eyes, as in all the pictures of Jesus from my Sunday School lessons. He grew up a Nazarene, despised and dismissed by His own people and oppressed by the occupation Roman government. His life didn’t matter to Pontius Pilate, the Roman governor who was trying to quell a riot nor did it matter to the religious authorities and the protestors who swapped His life for that of a known insurrectionist.

His life matters to all of us because we mattered to Him. He laid down His life in sacrifice for our lives – every least, lost, and last one of us. In Him is the ultimate end of racism, sexism, nationalism, ethnicism, and all the other ways we divide to assert our superiority over the rest of humanity. In Him, there is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male, female, black, white, brown, yellow. This is not to say that we will be sexless and colorless in the new creation, for then we would not be human. We come in a wonderful array of colors. But these will no longer divide nor will they again be the platform for power of one over another.

We walk by faith and not by sight. Faith does not live in denial of what we see with our eyes; faith sees beyond to what already is in Christ and what will be in His coming. The reality before our eyes is that we have been blind to what is happening, how we got here, and how each of us in our own way has added to a collective narrative that some lives matter less than others. 

Black lives matter, because up until now they haven’t mattered nearly enough.

This article was revised slightly on June 14 to correct a factual error on segregation and an editorial ambiguity spotted by alert readers. – wmc

©2020 William M. Cwirla

Priest, Parent, and Prince – Tres Ordines

The Covid-19 Chronicles: Reflections in a Pandemic, Part 10

Those of us who grew up reciting Luther’s Small Catechism for our suppers will recall the Table of Duties, the last of the small catechism’s eight parts, and the most difficult to learn by heart. In the typical congregation’s catechism curriculum, there wasn’t much time left at the end of the season for the Table of Duties, so it didn’t always get the attention it deserves.

Continue reading

Sola Scientia

The Covid-19 Chronicles: Reflections in a Pandemic, Part 9

I’m a big fan of science. Having spent six years of my college and graduate education and the first seven of my vocational years in chemistry, science is in my intellectual DNA. As a pastor-theologian, the only chemistry I practice these days is in the kitchen and meticulously studying those fine-print sheets that accompany prescription medications. However, the recent Covid-19 crisis has reawakened my science brain. With hockey and baseball down for the season, I now spend my free time perusing abstracts from Cell, Nature, and JAMA, and watching scientists discuss real-time, collaborative science on a global scale. I may never return to sports. Who could have foreseen the day when Dr. Anthony Fauci of the NIH would have a bobblehead, a T-shirt, and a parody on Saturday Night Live? This is the revenge of the nerds.

Continue reading

Ecclesia Virtualis

The Covid-19 Chronicles : Reflections in a Pandemic, Part 8

“Our churches also teach that one holy church is to continue forever. This church is the assembly of saints in which the Gospel is taught purely and the sacraments are administered rightly.” – Augsburg Confession VII

The Covid-19 crisis has catapulted the church into the internet age of live-stream, Zoom, and audio/video services – the virtual printing press of our time. Unable to gather in groups due to health concerns, congregations are resorting to virtual gatherings as a placeholder for corporate worship. It’s the next best thing to being there. Or is it?

Continue reading

Eucharistic Ethics

The Covid-19 Chronicles : Reflections in a Pandemic, Part 7

In my last essay, Eucharistic Fasting, I attempted to explain from Lutheran first principles the reasons for my congregation’s abstaining from the Sacrament during this time of CoV-2 quarantine. It drew considerable discussion, both positively and negatively. Some of the criticism surprised me, coming from people with whom I normally agree. It was not my intention to pass judgment on the decisions of others nor to imply that I was “right” and others were “wrong.” As I read and thought through the responses, I considered that our situation might profitably be viewed through the lens of ethics.

Continue reading

Eucharistic Fasting

The Covid-19 Chronicles : Reflections in a Pandemic, Part 6

The Covid-19 pandemic has created something of a crisis of communion in the Church. The Orthodox churches have largely suspended communion where they cannot gather. So also have the Roman churches. For non-sacramental protestants, this is not as much of a problem because music, preaching, and Bible study can be live-streamed or recorded. But for the sacramental churches, quarantine at home measures pose a serious challenge to theology and practice. Many Lutheran churches have resorted to a variety of extraordinary measures, attempting to comply with local health directives and sanitary practices while offering the Sacrament to the faithful. These measures include serial small group communions, private communions, drive-in communions, and in a few cases, virtual communions over the internet.

Continue reading


The Covid-19 Chronicles : Reflections in a Pandemic, Part 5

“There were some present at that very time who told him of the Galileans whose blood Pilate had mingled with their sacrifices.  And he answered them, “Do you think that these Galileans were worse sinners than all the other Galileans, because they suffered thus?  I tell you, No; but unless you repent you will all likewise perish. Or those eighteen upon whom the tower in Siloam fell and killed them, do you think that they were worse offenders than all the others who dwelt in Jerusalem? I tell you, No; but unless you repent you will all likewise perish.” – Luke 13:1-5

I’ve chosen to title this essay “Metanoia” rather than the usual English rendering “repentance,” to avoid the common misunderstanding associated with the word. When we hear the word “repent,” especially coming from religious circles (though it is not originally a religious word), we tend to think in terms of “stop sinning and straighten out your life,” in the way of a Kentucky revival preacher.

Continue reading

Word and Prayer

The Covid-19 Chronicles : Reflections in a Pandemic, Part 4

“I was in the Spirit on the Lord’s Day….” Revelation 1:10

John was in exile on the island of Patmos, a bishop separated from his congregations. He had neither pulpit nor altar. It was Sunday, the Lord’s Day, the Day of Resurrection. What was John to do on his island of exile? John prayed. He was “in the Spirit,” worshipping in spirit and truth.

When the church is gathered as a body, we speak of “Word and Sacrament.” This is what the gathered church is gathered around – the preaching of the Word, the Breaking of the Bread, and the communal prayers of the church (Acts 2:42). This is the church’s koinonia, her common life together. But what happens when the church is scattered, for whatever reason, be it persecution or pestilence? What then?

Continue reading

Exiled in Babylon

The Covid-19 Chronicles : Reflections in a Pandemic, Part 3

When the Babylonians ransacked Jerusalem and destroyed the temple in 586 BC, the residents of Judea were carried off into exile, as prophesied by Jeremiah, who didn’t exactly win popularity points with a people who thought they were invincible as God’s chosen people. During their years in Babylon, the Israelites built homes, raised families, opened businesses, and settled into life in a land not their own. Some, like Daniel, Shadrach, Mishach, and Abednigo rose to high positions in the Babylonian government. 

Continue reading

A Shake Test

The Covid-19 Chronicles : Reflections in a Pandemic, Part 2

I remember my 8th grade art teacher, whose classes were not so much art as they were craft. Lots of styrofoam, tooth picks, paper mache, white glue, and tempera paint. When evaluating our work, she would always pick it up and give it a firm shake to see how well it was constructed. “If it’s going to last, it has to be made well,” she’d say.

Continue reading